capri0mni: text icon "Writer's Block" (blocked!)
Ann ([personal profile] capri0mni) wrote2016-02-08 08:34 am

"Monsters' Legacy" decisions and frustrations


Image description: The words "Writer's Block," with 'Writer's' smashing into a lengthened ascender of the 'k,' as though into a wall.


So: in revisiting Monster's Legacy, I've decided to rearrange the chapter order. From the beginning, I'd been working on the assumption that I'd start with the autobiographical poems in vaguely chronological order, and putting the poems based on "fables and fairy tales" somewhere near the end (like, maybe the penultimate chapter, before I close it up with more personal poems again).

I've now decided that the fairy tale poems should come first, because: 1) that's how people already categorize monsters, so the first (cognitive) step is less of a doozy, and 2) it will set up the context I want for my primary argument that: "Mainstream anxieties about disability are as just as rational as anxieties over the bogeyman."

And because this fables chapter will be my foundation, I've also realized it has to be broader and more substantial than it is now; it currently contains four poems, one of which I'm going to throw out,* one of which is based on a mostly unknown story (in America),** and a third which is based on an unfamiliar version of an 'old favorite'.***

That means: I have more poems to write! ... A-a-and part of me is wondering if this is a legitimate decision, or just a delaying tactic so I can put off finishing the thing, and face up to the risk and terror of actually publishing and selling it. I'm not sure which side of that argument is being voiced by brain weasels, either.


There's the "decision" half of my writer's block.

The "frustration" half comes from not finding the source material I want to link back to for a few of those new poems -- especially the poem I want to write about Hephaestus (yeah -- yet another relatively obscure character, but it'll involve name-dropping the really famous gods). I could swear (By Hermes, naturally) that, back in early 2011, I read that Plato argued that artists should not make images of Hephaestus, because people might take depictions of his physical disability as literally true, rather than a metaphor, and that would tarnish the idea of gods as perfect, and thus, would be blasphemous (This is what inspired me to title my brief folklore blog: "Plato's Nightmare/Aesop's Dream"). Only, now, no matter what keywords I put into search engines, I can't find anything even close to that.

Other stories I want to write (about), and now cannot find anywhere: An e-text of the 14th C. romance of Aesop, which spells out how he was physically disabled black African ex-slave (I can buy a book of the translation from Amazon, but I want to have an online version, durnit!), and the story about the "real" Mother Goose was Charlemagne's grandmother, and how she had one enormous, deformed, (goose-like) foot, and walked with a crutch.****

So I am now appealing to my circles for help with Google-fu. Halp?! Any ideas?



*The one about the fable my mother told about Disability, adaptation, and trying to appease 'expert' authorities. She mistakenly attributed it to Aesop, but I figured out in 2011(ish) that she'd actually made it up on her own, probably based on her experience with doctors, therapists, and me. Writing a poetic version of an 'ancient' story, and trying to tell the story about how that first story never really existed, but was forgotten and then invented (all in the same piece) is just too meta- to fit into a chapter of "Story Time."

**Hans-my-Hedgehog, which is great, but infuriating when read as a disability metaphor. I could not bring myself to retell it straight -- my poem is a fix-it fic. Here's a link to an English translation of the original: http://www.pitt.edu/~dash/grimm108.html

***The Frog King, which, yeah, is famous. But in the version I'm telling, the princess actually tries to kill the frog, which is what breaks the spell. And then, the now-human king sleeps in the bed with her while she's portrayed as a child, and he's implied to be maturely adult (Though not "old," he's a full-fledged king, who is returning to the responsibilities of the throne, and she's the youngest princess-- still young enough to weep bitterly over the loss of a favorite toy). Yup, a whole lot darker and more sexualized than the bowdlerized, Victorian, version everyone knows. And here's a link to an English translation of that story: http://www.pitt.edu/~dash/grimm001.html

****Neither of these stories have any solid link to actual history, by the way (which is probably why, if they were online once. they are no longer -- such is our current culture's fear of ambiguous "truth"). But frankly, I really do not care at all about that -- for me, what's important is that these stories were told in the first place, and in the telling both illustrate and reinforce attitudes toward disability and other otherness.
spiralsheep: Orac says, "No." (chronographia Computer Says NO)

[personal profile] spiralsheep 2016-02-09 11:00 am (UTC)(link)
This is the old diff of that wiki article (from Dec 2011 until April 2012 so covering the time period) but it doesn't mention what you're looking for:

https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Bertrada_of_Laon&oldid=466236750
spiralsheep: Sheep wearing an eyepatch (spiralsheep Ram Raider mpfc)

[personal profile] spiralsheep 2016-02-08 05:58 pm (UTC)(link)
I figured out in 2011(ish) that she'd actually made it up on her own

If you want to find it, I think our conversation about that was around the beginning of 2012 when I first suggested writing a cycle of monster poems:

http://capriuni.dreamwidth.org/626046.html

So just before that post? Although the conversation might've been in my journal, I suppose.
spiralsheep: Orac says, "No." (chronographia Computer Says NO)

[personal profile] spiralsheep 2016-02-08 06:09 pm (UTC)(link)
I remember us having a detailed conversation about the sources your mother drew on for her tale but I've had a quick click through your dw backwards from that post and I suspect it was in the comments of my dw.
davidgillon: A pair of crutches, hanging from coat hooks, reflected in a mirror (Default)

[personal profile] davidgillon 2016-02-08 07:52 pm (UTC)(link)
If you're thinking of doing something for Hephaestus*, then you might consider roping in the other disabled smith gods** - it's almost a motif ;) And googling that turned up the two of us from your 2011 BADD post - http://platosnightmare-aesopsdream.blogspot.co.uk/2011/05/lame-smith-god-and-two-sides-of-myth.html (which I'd vaguely remembered, but completely forgotten was by you, or that I'd commented).

* I looked at that picture of Hephaestus on the donkey in your essay, and my immediate reaction this time was 'that's either phocomelia, or Proximal Femoral Focal Deficit' - making me wonder if the painter/potter had painted it from life.

** Wayland's the obvious one, but I've got a niggling feeling there's a West African one as well, and there's definitely the Egyptian Ptah (not always shown as disabled, but there's an alternate representation of him with dwarfism), who the Greeks syncretized with Hephaestus***. Googling Ptah and disability threw me this link https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=FIGiAgAAQBAJ&pg=PA152&lpg=PA152&dq=ptah+disability&source=bl&ots=YFHGr1V_Cs&sig=T-xMwe7so2-0opcBnVHEF_f4Bfk&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjfp_q68OjKAhVCjg8KHTMXBoMQ6AEIJTAA#v=onepage&q=ptah%20disability&f=false and I'm fairly certain I've never seen the story of Nimmah before, but that Babylonian myth is brilliant!

*** http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10076885 (wince for the use of 'buffoon' in utterly ableist manner in the second last sentence, but the rest of the abstract is fascinating)
davidgillon: A pair of crutches, hanging from coat hooks, reflected in a mirror (Default)

[personal profile] davidgillon 2016-02-09 06:23 am (UTC)(link)
I don't think that's an unreasonable argument. I do think it would be fairly limiting having to work sitting down for some of the more active physical work, but not entirely impossible, and eminently possible for smaller scale work such as silver-smithing.
davidgillon: A pair of crutches, hanging from coat hooks, reflected in a mirror (Default)

[personal profile] davidgillon 2016-02-09 02:07 pm (UTC)(link)
(Any more than being a skilled blues singer will make you blind -- just saying).

ROFL!
igenlode: The pirate sloop 'Horizon' from "Treasures of the Indies" (Default)

[personal profile] igenlode 2016-02-09 11:27 pm (UTC)(link)
Plato and Hephaestos: were you thinking of Plato's "Republic", Book 2, in which he argues that "the hurling out of heaven of Hephaestus by his father when he was trying to save his mother from a beating" comes under the heading of stories that should not be told to the young, since the young are not able to distinguish between what is and is not allegory? (Plat. Rep. 2.378d)